Skip to content

Sue de Coq (AALS) ​

Loading demo...

Sue de Coq uses the intersection of a box and a row or column (the non-box house) to contribute cells to an ALS or AALS in each house, forming two locked sets and enabling eliminations. This page covers the AALS form, where the intersection contains three unfilled cells and exactly one side uses an AALS (almost-almost locked set).

How to spot it ​

  • Check each intersection with exactly three unfilled cells, together with its box and non-box house (row or column).
  • Outside the intersection, find an ALS (one more distinct candidate than cells) in one house and an AALS (two more distinct candidates than cells) in the other.
  • The intersection must contain at least four distinct candidates, satisfying these conditions:
    • All come from the ALS and AALS, with no extra candidate.
    • At least two come from the ALS side.
    • At least two come from the AALS side.
    • The two candidate groups are disjoint. (The ALS and AALS themselves may contain the same candidates, but those candidates must be absent from the intersection.)
  • At least two intersection cells contain candidates from the AALS side.
  • Eliminations:
    • Eliminate the box ALS's (or AALS's) candidates from box cells outside both that set and the intersection.
    • Eliminate the non-box ALS's (or AALS's) candidates from cells in the non-box house outside both that set and the intersection.
Sue de Coq (AALS)

How it works ​

An ALS has one more distinct candidate than cells in a single house. If one other cell in the same house must take a digit from the ALS's candidates, together they form a locked set, allowing eliminations. An AALS has two more distinct candidates than cells in a single house. If two other cells in the same house must take digits from the AALS's candidates, together they form a locked set, allowing eliminations.

ALS and AALS
ALS and AALS

Once the conditions in the previous section are met, we can deduce the following: two of the three intersection cells must take digits from the AALS side, and one from the ALS side.

Any other arrangement in the intersection would leave some cell in one of the sets with no digit left to place, violating Sudoku rules:

  • If all three unfilled intersection cells took digits from the AALS side, they and the AALS (n-2 cells with n candidates) would form a structure of n+1 cells with only n candidates. At least one cell could not be filled without repeating a digit.
  • If all three unfilled intersection cells took digits from the ALS side, they and the ALS (n-1 cells with n candidates) would form a structure of n+2 cells with only n candidates. Two cells could not be filled without repeating a digit.
  • If two unfilled intersection cells took digits from the ALS and the other took a digit from the AALS, the ALS side would have n+1 cells with only n candidates, leaving one cell unfillable. (The AALS side would have m-1 cells with m candidates: an ALS. This does not violate Sudoku rules, but it does not lock the set and can be ignored for the current analysis.)

Therefore, only one arrangement is consistent with Sudoku rules:

  • Two unfilled intersection cells take digits from the AALS, and the other takes a digit from the ALS.

This gives the following conclusions:

  • Two intersection cells form a locked set with the AALS. In the AALS's house, its candidates can be eliminated from cells outside both the AALS and the intersection.
  • The other intersection cell forms a locked set with the ALS. In the ALS's house, its candidates can be eliminated from cells outside both the ALS and the intersection.

Examples ​

15767812568256781578178579678956895678591258957825782578157891789389589235812581292939237272795958967896781678179367936956785678567858917967916567825898925939414323464766145824324185421963743

In the board above, box 1 and row 2 contain an AALS Sue de Coq structure. In box 1, R1C2 is an AALS (one cell with three candidates); in row 2, R2C9 is an ALS (one cell with two candidates).

Of all the candidates in the intersection, {6, 7, 8} come from the AALS R1C2, and {5, 9} come from the ALS R2C9. These two groups are disjoint. The cases to consider are:

  • All three cells take digits from {6, 7, 8}. The three cells themselves would form a locked set (a naked triple), leaving R1C2 with no digit to place and violating Sudoku rules.
  • Two cells take digits from {5, 9}. Those two cells themselves would form a locked set (a naked pair), leaving R2C9 with no digit to place and violating Sudoku rules.
  • Two cells take digits from {6, 7, 8}, and the other takes a digit from {5, 9}. This is the only arrangement consistent with Sudoku rules, so:
    • The two cells taking digits from {6, 7, 8} form a locked set with R1C2, allowing {6, 7, 8} to be eliminated from other cells in box 1.
    • The cell taking a digit from {5, 9} forms a locked set with R2C9, allowing {5, 9} to be eliminated from other cells in row 2.

682928967279464526812689156291289295812891572789172329256359569269562625676793461414556735756723123127172468168162414451513457334671488314982654985739897326

In the board above, box 2 and row 2 contain an AALS Sue de Coq structure. In the box, {R1C5, R3C5} is an AALS (two cells with four candidates); in the row, {R2C1, R2C3} is an ALS (two cells with three candidates).

Of all the candidates in the intersection, {1, 2, 8, 9} come from the AALS, and {5, 6} come from the ALS. By the reasoning for the AALS form of Sue de Coq:

  • Two intersection cells must take two digits from {1, 2, 8, 9}. They form a locked set with the AALS, allowing {1, 2, 8, 9} to be eliminated from other cells in the box.
  • The remaining intersection cell must take one digit from {5, 6}. It forms a locked set with the ALS, allowing {4, 5, 6} to be eliminated from other cells in the row. (The resulting set is a naked triple, so all three candidates in the ALS can be used for eliminations.)