Sue de Coq (Extra)
Loading demo...
Sue de Coq uses the intersection of a box and a row or column (the non-box house) to contribute one cell to an ALS in each house, forming two locked sets and enabling eliminations. This page covers the Extra form, where all three unfilled intersection cells participate and there is exactly one extra candidate absent from both ALSs.
How to spot it
- Check each intersection with exactly three unfilled cells, together with its box and non-box house (row or column).
- Find one ALS in each house, outside the intersection. Call them the box ALS and the non-box ALS.
- The intersection must contain at least five distinct candidates, satisfying these conditions:
- At least two come from the box ALS.
- At least two come from the non-box ALS.
- Exactly one extra candidate belongs to neither ALS.
- These three groups are disjoint and account for every candidate in the intersection. (The ALSs themselves may contain the same candidates, but those candidates must be absent from the intersection.)
- Eliminations:
- Eliminate the box ALS's candidates from box cells outside both the box ALS and the intersection.
- Eliminate the non-box ALS's candidates from cells in the non-box house outside both that ALS and the intersection.
- Eliminate the extra candidate from cells outside the intersection in both houses.
How it works
Once the above conditions are met, we can deduce the following: one intersection cell must take the extra digit; of the remaining two, one must take a digit from the box ALS and the other from the non-box ALS.
Any other arrangement in the intersection would leave some cell in one of the ALSs with no digit left to place, violating Sudoku rules:
- If the extra digit were not placed in the intersection, at least two of the three unfilled cells would have to take digits from the same ALS. Those two cells and that ALS (
n-1cells withncandidates) would form a structure ofn+1cells with onlyncandidates, leaving one cell in the ALS unfillable. - After one cell takes the extra digit, if the remaining two cells both take digits from the same ALS, they and that ALS would likewise form a structure of
n+1cells with onlyncandidates, leaving one cell in the ALS unfillable.
Therefore, only one arrangement is consistent with Sudoku rules:
- One intersection cell takes the extra digit, one takes a digit from the box ALS, and the other takes a digit from the non-box ALS.
This gives the following conclusions:
- The extra digit is confined to the intersection and can be eliminated from all other cells in both houses.
- The box ALS and its corresponding intersection cell form a locked set. Its candidates can be eliminated from box cells outside both the box ALS and the intersection.
- The non-box ALS and the other intersection cell form a locked set. Its candidates can be eliminated from cells in the non-box house outside both that ALS and the intersection.
Examples
In the board above, the intersection of box 1 and row 2 has three unfilled cells with candidates {1, 3, 5, 6, 8}. Of these, {3, 8} come from the bivalue ALS R3C1 in box 1, and {1, 5} come from the bivalue ALS R2C6 in row 2. The intersection also contains an extra candidate, 6. These three sets of digits are disjoint, forming an Extra Sue de Coq structure.
One intersection cell must take the extra digit 6; of the remaining two, one must take a digit from {3, 8} and the other from {1, 5}.
If 6 were not placed in the intersection, two of the three cells would have to take two digits from the same ALS, leaving that ALS with too few digits to fill its cells.
The same reasoning applies to the remaining two cells: if both took digits from the same ALS (so that neither took a digit from the other ALS), that ALS would be left with too few digits to fill its cells.
The extra digit 6 is therefore confined to the intersection and can be eliminated from other cells in the box and row, such as R1C3:6 and R2C4:6. The intersection cell that takes a digit from {3, 8} forms a naked pair with R3C1 in box 1, allowing 3 and 8 to be eliminated from other cells in box 1. The intersection cell that takes a digit from {1, 5} forms a naked pair with R2C6 in row 2, allowing 1 and 5 to be eliminated from other cells in row 2.
The board above contains an Extra Sue de Coq structure in box 3 and column 7. The intersection candidates {1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 9} fall into three disjoint groups: {3, 7, 9} come from the ALS in box 3, {1, 4} come from the ALS in column 7, and the remaining digit, 5, is the extra candidate.